TV critics gushing about surprise-hit Privileged
Tuesday, September 16th, 2008
When Gilmore Girls premiered back in the Fall of 2000, I was (foolishly) determined to avoid adding another so-called ‘chick show’ to my Felicity and Buffy regimen. But a co-worker had snagged a screener copy and implored me to check it out. I wound up calling her halfway thru the episode to say how brilliant it was—and remained happily devoted until the series concluded. Now, TV reviewers are noting Gilmore similarities in Privileged, the new CW sleeper-hit dramedy which flew under the promotional radar, but has quickly struck a chord with critics and fans. Here’s just a small sample of the national acclaim:
“Gilmore Girls fans will dig the whip smart dialogue and literary references.” – Rolling Stone
“It has the spunk and sparkly, fun writing of Gilmore with the super-wealthy backdrop of Gossip. Privileged might quietly turn out to be the (CW’s) best.” — Columbus Dispatch
“Privileged has style and wit. Joanna Garcia is all bright eyes and charm, and it’s a treat watching her shine.” — The Detroit News
“CW’s Privileged offers a wealth of humor.” – Boston Herald
“Joanna Garcia’s engaging performance as the ‘fish out of water’ lead raises this teen drama above Gossip Girl variety of series. It also emphasizes the importance of intelligence and values, rather than just clothes and cattiness.” — San Antonio Express-News
“The CW’s Privileged has rich dramatic potential.” — Pittsburg Post-Gazette
“Privileged is a bright, bouncy fairy tale of power and extravagance, tempered by reminders that money can’t buy happiness.” – Ky. Courier-Journal
If you detect a familiar tone while watching Privileged, it’s because series creator and writer Rina Mimoun was a hands-on executive producer for both Gilmore Girls and Everwood. That’s what you call a solid pedigree.
Privileged / All New! Tuesday 9pm, after 90210


We got our first look at the 90210/Privileged pairing last night, and aside from the ‘family bowling night’ plot wedged into the first hour, this promises to be a solid evening of drama and quirky comedy for a long time. The CW can credit two blonde actresses for much of the success. While I didn’t see her work on the original series, Jennie Garth (Kelly) is a real force in Beverly Hills. She, of course, proved very adept at physical comedy on What I Like About You, but in confronting her drunken mother (a delicious guest-shot by semi-retired Ann Gillespie), Jennie’s dramatic skills rose to a new level—their scene was easily the episode’s highpoint. The bubbly actress represents the key link between 90210 generations, as fans eagerly await the revelation of which former boyfriend is her son’s deadbeat dad. Later, Joanna Garcia (newly-red and loving it) lived up to the non-stop press accolades she’s received, appearing in nearly every moment of Privileged and nailing an array of emotional showdowns. If Hollywood hadn’t taken notice before, they’re seeing one of the most-talented and winsome young actresses on television. Series creator and writer Rita Mimoun (of Everwood and Gilmore Girls fame) compares her to Lauren Graham, which is off-the-charts praise. And talk about seamless-compatibility: The CW’s Monday and Tuesday 9pm dramas have retained nearly 100% of their lead-in audiences. Your thoughts?
Watching this week’s series premiere of 90210, I became very appreciative that Shannen Doherty agreed to reprise her role as ‘Brenda Walsh’ fourteen years after she unceremoniously left the original zip. Few TV actresses are as compelling and addictive—her talents elevated the first three seasons of Charmed—and this four-episode stint was a big score for The CW. Shannen’s legendary off-screen antics seem to have only enhanced her charismatic image, whether it’s a battle with ‘90s co-stars Jennie Garth and Tori Spelling, shockingly-brief marriages to Ashley Hamilton and Rick Salomon, or run-ins with L.A. traffic cops. Spelling’s recent memoir labels Shannen a “bad influence,” and this week’s National Enquirer headline proclaims she’s ‘terrorizing the set’ of 90210. Fun reading, maybe…but it’s fiction, as Doherty and Garth have patched up their formerly-tense relationship, and young star Shenae Grimes (Annie) praises the 37-year-old actress for helping her navigate the early grind of a pop-culture hit. Of course, 90210 is a soapy drama, so Brenda Walsh won’t be leaving the Hills without some heated exchanges—maybe even some retribution for Kelly stealing Dylan away from her back in the day (click below!). Trust me, these next three episodes are not to be missed.
Sunday nights will be laced with biting comedy. That’s my first impression after watching The CW Fall Preview Show, which airs twice this coming weekend. Hosted by Privileged stars Joanna Garcia and Anne Archer, the half-hour special gives an overview of our seven new network series—including a first peek at the Sunday lineup, where laughter rules. Two actresses simply jump off the screen in their roles: Jaime Murray on Valentine and Laurie Metcalf on Easy Money. Noted for her characters on Hustle and Dexter, sultry British-born Jaime camps it up (incognito) as Greek goddess of love Aphrodite; while in “the world of payday loans,” Laurie thinks more like Tony Soprano than an offbeat mother running the family biz. We also get a glimpse of original Beverly Hills mommie dearest “Jackie Taylor,” played by returning 90210 alum Ann Gillespie. Look for a big showdown between her and daughter Kelly (Jennie Garth) concerning offspring issues early this fall. The preview show follows a Jason Priestley movie (Calendar Girl) this Saturday, so we’re in full 90210 mode. Check out the teasers, then get ready for the real thing Monday night when Season Premiere Week begins on WBNX.
